Symbolbild (Stockfoto); nicht das abgebildete Produkt.
The One That Started It
The Toddy has been in production since the 1960s and is the reference point for immersion cold brew. Grounds and water sit in a brewing container for twelve to twenty-four hours; pulling a rubber stopper drains the concentrate through a reusable felt pad into a glass decanter.
The felt is the whole design. It filters far more finely than a mesh screen while still passing some oils, which gives Toddy concentrate a rounder, heavier character than the cleaner mesh-and-paper systems.
The Felt Filter And Its Upkeep
The felt pad is reusable for many batches but requires real care: rinsed thoroughly after each brew and then stored wet in the fridge, sealed. Left to dry out it stiffens, and left unsealed it takes on smells.
Owners who abandon the Toddy almost always cite the filter routine rather than the coffee. It is not difficult, but it is a commitment and it is easy to forget.
The rubber stopper deserves a mention of its own. It is what holds several litres of liquid in place for a full day, and it is a friction fit rather than a mechanism. Seating it firmly and checking it before filling is the single habit that prevents the failure mode owners most regret, which is a drained brew across a worktop overnight.
The Concentrate
The result is smooth, low in perceived acidity and full bodied — the flavour profile most people mean when they say they prefer cold brew to iced filter. It is sweeter and rounder than what the OXO produces with a paper filter.
Like all cold brew concentrate, it keeps around two weeks refrigerated and is diluted to taste at serving.
Dose matters more than time with this system. Because the felt passes oils, an over-dosed Toddy brew turns heavy and slightly muddy rather than simply strong, which is a different failure from the sharp over-extraction a paper system gives. Following the supplied ratio closely for the first few batches is worth the discipline.
Against The Alternatives
Against the OXO, this is heavier and rounder where the OXO is cleaner and brighter, and it is more work to maintain. Which is better is a matter of taste rather than quality.
Against a jar and a sieve, the Toddy produces a genuinely different cup because of the felt — this is not merely convenience.
Who Should Not Buy It
Anyone who will not keep up the filter routine should buy a mesh system instead. A neglected felt pad ruins a batch and there is no way around the upkeep.
Anyone who prefers a clean, tea-like cold brew is buying the wrong profile. The felt is designed to pass body, not remove it.
Compared with the Filtron, which pairs felt with a disposable paper liner, the Toddy keeps a pure felt character and avoids an ongoing consumable. The trade is that its pad picks up fines directly and therefore needs replacing more often — a running cost either way, just in a different form.
The Verdict
Sixty years on, the Toddy still makes the roundest, smoothest cold brew concentrate of the common home systems, and the felt filter is genuinely why.
It asks for a filter routine that a mesh brewer does not. Commit to that and it rewards you; skip it and you will be disappointed.
Auf einen Blick
Vorteile
- Felt filter gives a rounder, fuller concentrate than mesh
- Notably smooth and low in perceived acidity
- Simple, durable design with very little to break
- Reusable filter rather than a paper consumable
Nachteile
- Felt pad must be rinsed and stored wet and sealed after every batch
- Pad takes on odours if stored carelessly
- Wrong profile if you want a clean, tea-like cold brew
- Bulky two-vessel system to store
Häufig gestellte Fragen
How long does the felt filter last?
Many batches if cared for — commonly quoted as a few months of regular use. It is replaced when it stops draining freely or picks up a smell that rinsing will not shift.
Can I store the filter dry?
No. It must be stored wet, sealed and refrigerated. Drying it out stiffens the felt and changes how it drains.
How does it compare with mesh brewers?
Rounder and fuller, because the felt passes oils a paper filter removes while trapping fines a mesh lets through. Mesh-and-paper systems give a cleaner, brighter cup. Neither is better; they are different.
Spezifikationen
| Method | Immersion, 12–24 hours |
| Filtration | Reusable felt pad |
| Vessels | Brewing container plus glass decanter |
| Drain | Rubber stopper, gravity |
| Output | Concentrate, to be diluted |
| Filter care | Rinse, store wet and sealed, refrigerated |
| Fridge life | Approx. 2 weeks |
| In production since | 1960s |
Fazit
The roundest, smoothest cold brew concentrate of the common systems — if you keep up the felt filter routine. Buy a mesh brewer instead if you know you won't.
Preis auf Amazon prüfen